Which wheels will fit better?

Both options are avant garde m550 wheels in silver, my car is lowered on tein street advance coilovers, I am willing to get my fenders rolled:

19x8.5 35 offset, 245 tires all around

Or

19x9.5 33 offset, 245 tires all around

***sorry if there's a thread similar to this but I couldn't find it

So which will fit better and which will look better?